The most likely cluster is the cluster with the largest likelihood ratio in the cluster analysis. An introduction to satscan software to measure spatial, temporal or spacetime clusters. Use of a spatial scan statistic to identify clusters of. The satscan macro accessory for cartography smac package. A procedure for detecting childhood cancer clusters near hazardous waste sites in florida.
Health, general environmental issues bad debts cancer research cancer clusters cancer in children distribution risk factors cancer research childhood cancer cluster analysis methods hazardous waste sites health aspects oncology. The most likely cluster located by the spatial scan statistic is represented by a circle. Chitwan district was identified as the most likely cluster and jhapa district was the first secondary cluster in both spatial and spatiotemporal scan. These can be used in a class room setting, as part of a course on disease surveillance, spatial epidemiology, medical geography, or spatial statistics. There are a number of other software packages that are related to the satscan software. Commonly, this programs installer has the following filename. Spatiotemporal analysis of dengue fever in nepal from 2010. Using the satscan method to detect local malaria clusters. Clusters of spatial, temporal, and spacetime distribution.
The most popular versions among the software users are 9. The output from satscan included information regarding individual points contained in each cluster. The highrisk areas with a relative risk greater than three, including the most likely cluster area and two secondary cluster areas, were mainly concentrated in the southwest of qinghai. We will run a cluster detection analysis on the north humberside dataset using the spatial scan statistic and the satscan software. The satscan software was used for analysis of clusters of aros in the different municipalities of the region 22, 23. A procedure for detecting childhood cancer clusters near. Background examining whether disease cases are clustered in. Satscan was configured to detect purely spatial clusters with a bernoulli casecontrol model. The most likely cluster found by satscan with this subset of data is the same 43 cases in the most likely cluster with all of the ohio data, but the pvalue is now 0.
Using the kulldorffs scan statistical analysis to detect spatio. The most likely cluster is the cluster that is the most likely cluster not to be due to chance. Perform geographical surveillance of disease, to detect spatial or spacetime disease clusters, and to see if they are statistically significant. This free software is an intellectual property of satscan. Hemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome hfrs is a rodentborne disease caused by hantavirus, with characteristics of fever, hemorrhage, kidney damage, and hypotension. Pdf a satscan macro accessory for cartography smac. Satscan software for the spatial, temporal, and space. Most of the studies analyzing spatiotemporal patterns of dengue have used satscan and geoda public domain software 19, 27, 28, 31. Retrospective spacetime analysis of clusters indicating high schistosomiasis infection rate using the discrete poisson model by satscan. The emst method captured a greater extent of the true cluster f tc than satscan for all cluster types 2.
Using monte carlo hypothesis testing, the p value assigned to each cluster is adjusted for the multiple testing inherent in the large number of circles evaluated. Spatial scan statistics adjusted for multiple clusters. Homicidesuicide in the state of florida a cluster analysis using satscan by sheryl zavertnik b. In satscan software, there are advanced output features of criteria. The scan parameters, for time range from 2006 to 2015 with time interval of one year and analysis was spacetime. The most common analysis is to scan for areas with high rates only. Satscan software provides a powerful tool to detect. Sometimes though, the primary interest is to find areas with a low rate. Seven clusters one most likely cluster and six likely secondary clusters were detected in poyang lake region from 2009 to 2014, which meaning a statistically significant both in space and time in these areas. Output for the most likely cluster and two secondary clusters. Optimizing the maximum reported cluster size in the spatial. A cluster analysis of pediatric cancer incidence rates in florida.
The one with the maximum likelihood is most likely cluster least likely to have occurred by chance. A comparison of spatial clustering and cluster detection. I specified that no cluster should center in a more likely cluster. In addition to the most likely cluster, there can be secondary clusters with. Satscan method to detect local malaria clusters for guiding malaria control programmes. To identify the spacetime clusters of df transmission a discrete poisson model was performed using satscan software. Ebert, fellow, ieee abstract kulldorffs spatial scan statistic and the software implementation satscan are widely used for the detection and evalu ation of geographic clusters, particularly within the health care community. A cluster analysis of pediatric cancer incidence rates in. Spacetime clusters of dengue fever in bangladesh shahera banu 1, wenbiao hu2, cameron hurst. A common method used for example by the software satscan12, is to. Satscan is a free software which analyzes spatial, temporal and spacetime data using the spatial, temporal, or spacetime scan. As far as we are aware, satscan software has not been used previously to identify clusters of births outside health facilities.
The spatial scan statistic is one of the main epidemiological tools to test for the presence of disease clusters in a geographical region. Satscan is a software program written to implement the scan statistic. This software s spatial scan is one of the best for power, and although it has low levels of sensitivity, it is comparable with other similar products and results in fewer false positives. Hfrs is recognized as a notifiable public health problem in china, and liaoning province is one of the most seriously affected areas with the most cases in china. There is freely available software called satscantm kulldorff and. Satscan was chosen because it is the most thoroughly evaluated software for detecting spatiotemporal clusters of infectious diseases. Bio284 computer lab 6 spatial cluster detection for binary. To detect the spatial clustering and high risk areas of pulmonary. International journal of health geographics 2007, 6. Using gini coefficient to determining optimal cluster. It must often be run multiple times per day when doing disease surveillance. Running satscan frequently via its graphical user interface can be cumbersome, and the output can be difficult to visualize. We tested those methods on a large, diverse, realworld data set, and evaluated one of the most commonly used cluster detection software products. The circle with the maximum likelihood is the most likely cluster, that is, the cluster least likely to be due to chance.
Geographic clusters in underimmunization and vaccine. To detect noncircular clusters which cannot be detected by kulldor s circular. Spacetime clusters of dengue fever in bangladesh monash. Results spacetime distribution of df transmission was clustered during three periods 20002002, 20032005 and 20062009. A comparative study on satscan and flexscan software for. Score each location by how likely it is to have an.
Most secondary clusters overlap with and some only differ slightly with a more likely cluster. In satscan, the largest possible value of the maximum cluster length is half the analysis time period. The spatial scan statistic 7 was applied on the two samples. The purely spatial analysis of the faptp dataset at the zcta level on brain tumorcns cancer rates adjusted for age and sex with the satscan software revealed one significant most likely cluster in the southern part of the state, close to miami. The graph shows that brain tumor rates in the cluster stayed above the florida rates almost each year. While a map is not required for the output to be useful, many users probably use the satscan results to imagine or draw the cluster on a map.
Selection of the maximum spatial cluster size of the. In addition to the most likely cluster, satscan also designates secondary clusters for purely spatial and spatiotemporal analyses and ranks them according to their estimated llr statistic. Satscan statistic identifies the most likely unusual cluster 2427. Spatial, temporal, and spatiotemporal analysis of under. The purely temporal cluster analysis indicated that one most likely cluster was identified in all districts llr 2109.
Satscan methodology was used by the malaria control programme to detect local malaria clusters to assist disease control planning. Satscan software identifies most likely significant cluster over space, time or both. The highlighted subset of counties and most likely cluster are visualized in figure figure9. Results from scanning of the two methods showed that the most likely clusters. For example, if you have one year 365 days of data to scan, the largest value that satscan will accept is 182 days. When applied to the breast cancer data set with 15 year latency, both the m statistic and the gam indicate differences in the spatial distribution of cases and controls that are very unlikely to be explained by chance. The maximum spatial cluster size is the only parameter that must be selected by users to apply commonly used circular spatial scan statistics with satscan software. Perform geographical surveillance of disease, to detect spatial or spacetime disease clusters, and to.
Optimizing the maximum reported cluster size in the spatial scan. Satscan identified a geographic area in northern anhui province as the most likely endemic cluster region. Villagebased spatiotemporal cluster analysis of the. While the statistical significance of the most likely cluster is correctly assessed using the model assumptions, secondary clusters tend to have conservatively high p values. Satscan is a free software that analyzes spatial, temporal and spacetime data using the spatial, temporal, or spacetime scan statistics. The epidemiological characteristics and spatiotemporal. Scan statistic, satscan, cluster detection, cancer mortality, log likelihood ratio, cluster reporting size, gini. Clustering was performed using purely spatial, temporal, and spatialtemporal scenarios, separately. In this paper, we propose a sequential version of the spatial scan statistic to. Densityequalizing euclidean minimum spanning trees for.
The annual most likely cluster extended first from 2009 to 2012, then. Kulldor 1997 developed a circular spatial scan statistic for identifying the most likely cluster of disease that maximizes the likelihood ratio and his software satscan has been widely used for geographical disease cluster detection and disease surveillance. Results show that the distribution of dengue fever was not random but clustered in space and time. An open source software for fast gridbased datamining in spatial.
Figure 1 shows the annual unadjusted brain tumor rates for florida and for the most likely cluster based on what is shown in figure 2. The third season for case cluster identification overlapped with the first season of implementing an outbreak identification and response system in. Consequently, it was possible to compare features of the simulated cluster with features of the most likely cluster identified by satscan. A spatial scan statistic with a restricted likelihood ratio. Preventing chronic disease applying spatial analysis. While these secondary clusters are always evaluated as part of an analysis, it is not meaningful to report all of them. The exportation module was used to put data into the right format and analyze them with the satscan software 11. July to september of 2010 was identified as a significant temporal cluster. Spatial data analysis geographic information systems.
Application of a poisson distribution to the epidemiology of a rare disease such as imd is appropriate, although in practice the null hypothesis i. They can also be used for selfstudy, or as part of a group project. Dhaka was the most likely cluster for df in all three periods. Using the kulldorffs scan statistical analysis to detect. Satscan spatial scan clusters were consistent with those detected by. Spatial analysis of malaria in anhui province, china. Scan statistics are used to detect anomalous clusters in spatial or spacetime data. The aim of the present study was to use satscan to identify and evaluate clusters of births that occurred outside of ghanaian health facilities for targeted intervention. Optimizing the maximum reported cluster size in the. With the satscan software, it is possible to scan for areas with high rates of the disease, for areas with low rates of the disease, or simultaneously for areas with either high or low rates. Satscan is a free software that analyzes spatial, temporal and spacetime data.
Using gini coefficient to determining optimal cluster reporting sizes for spatial scan statistics. Satscan gives pvalues comparing the score from the most likely cluster to the score of most likely clusters under h0. The window with the maximum likelihood ratio is the most likely cluster. The center of the most likely cluster area was located in dari county, 33. It is designed for any of the following interrelated purposes. A satscan macro accessory for cartography smac package. Satscan tutorials satscan software for the spatial. The satscan software has several options on how to report overlapping clusters. However, the geographical range of df transmission.
These include i wrappers and macros, whereby satscan can be run as part of another software environment such as sas or r, ii software that calls and uses one or more satscan features as an integral part of the software, iii programs for displaying satscan results using the. Mpumalanga province, south africa is a low malaria transmission area that is subject to malaria epidemics. Privacy protection versus cluster detection in spatial. This study analysed the spatial distribution of malaria in anhui province, china, during 2000 to 2006 using the spatial smoothing and spatial scan statistic method. This parameter is the maximum size that the scanning window can reach as scaled in terms of spatial distance or percentage of the total population at risk 4. Mechanical engineering, the university of notre dame. Satscan software for the spatial, temporal, and spacetime scan. In order words, it identifies the cluster that is least likely to occur by chance. Significance is derived from ranking this likelihood ratio among 999 randomized.
887 1220 869 502 1382 99 80 613 1045 533 1457 1211 538 175 820 133 259 1223 243 1175 515 408 955 1483 1326 51 911 277 1020 782 524 552 1056 564 272 1014